Issue No. 27 Spring 2007 Tools Home Tools for Housing and Economic Development
 

Shawn Wallace, managing director of AS220, and Lucie Searle, AS200’s development manager, visit a Dreyfus Hotel apartment.



“We very much see ourselves as an alternative to some of the other development that is happening downtown.”


Shawn Wallace

 

Comeback Places: Affordable Housing for
Artists in Downtown Providence

By Robert O’Malley

View of Burlington Waterfront Apartments in Burlington, Vermont.

The renovation of the former Dreyfus Hotel preserves a historically significant downtown building while providing new affordable housing in a district where most of the new housing has been market rate.
  
“The ‘AS’ in AS220 stands for alternative space,” says Shawn Wallace, AS220’s managing director. “We very much see ourselves as an alternative to some of the other development that is happening downtown. Rents in Providence are going through the roof. It’s very hard for people who don’t make that much money to live in Providence neighborhoods, let alone downtown.”

Once completed the Dreyfus Hotel initiative will include 11 live-work spaces affordable to very low- and low-income artists, three market-rate units, as well as
10 work studios, gallery space, and a ground-floor restaurant.

Before it was converted to a dormitory for Johnson & Wales University in 1975,
the 19th century Dreyfus Hotel building had been used as a hotel, a lounge, and a restaurant. The current renovation includes preservation of historic architectural detail such as the ornate wood paneling
and decorative carving in the ground-floor restaurant space. “This is really the historic centerpiece of the building,” says Lucie Searle, development manager for AS200.

Financing for the restoration includes a $300,000 grant and a $710,047 subsidized advance from the Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston’s (the Bank) Affordable Housing Program (AHP) through member Bank Rhode Island. Other funding includes state and federal Historic Tax Credits, New Markets Tax Credits, and a predevelopment loan and bridge loan from member Bank of America Rhode Island, N.A.

“This is a $7.5 million project with about $1.5 million in permanent financing to be supported by the rents,” says Ms. Searle. “I think we really want to underscore the indispensability of the Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston funding piece. It not only involves a $300,000 grant, but provides us with permanent financing through the subsidized advance.”

View of Burlington Waterfront Apartments in Burlington, Vermont.

Ms. Searle also points to the critical role Johnson & Wales University played in keeping the downtown district alive during its most challenging years and for ensuring that the Dreyfus building was transferred
to AS220. “There were other people who wanted to buy the building, but they said they wanted to make this work for AS220 because of the affordable space it would provide for artists.”

Formed in 1986 by a small group of artists, AS220 acquired a blighted downtown building on Empire Street in the early 1990s and converted it to single-room residences and workspace for artists, a theater, and other performance space. In 1993, the Empire Street initiative was the recipient of an AHP grant through member Citizens Bank of Rhode Island.

“We have been on Empire Street for almost 15 years and have a waiting list for artists that need affordable space to live and work,” says Ms. Searle. “The motivation behind the Dreyfus was to do another affordable project that would keep us in the mix downtown.”

“Over the last 15 years we have been constantly looking at buildings,” says Mr. Wallace. “The Dreyfus was the first one where all of the pieces came together. I think we are doing the same thing now —
if something makes sense we may pursue another project. ”

Peter Walsh, senior vice president at member Bank Rhode Island, says the AS200 project will “diversify the population moving into downtown. It’s going to bring people back to the city and provide affordable housing in the downtown area, where the housing is typically more expensive. It’s better to have a broad mix of people living downtown.”

Mr. Walsh says the “availability of state Historic Tax Credits makes many downtown renovations more attractive and doable. Quite frankly, they probably couldn’t have done them without help from the tax credits,” he adds.

Developing affordable housing in historic buildings presents challenges that don’t exist with new construction, says Ms. Searle. Code issues require adaptations that can be expensive for a developer.  “Often what we want to use the buildings for today is not what they were designed for originally,” she says. “The challenge is how do you reuse them, make them relevant today, and keep them affordable. I think the first step is to keep them — some cities lost their historic buildings to the wrecking ball.”T