Issue No. 27 Spring 2007 Tools Home Tools for Housing and Economic Development
 

View of the AHP-funded Dartmouth Hotel in Dudley Square.



Critical to the revival has been the work of Nuestra Comunidad Development Corporation, Madison Park Development Corporation, and Dorchester Bay Economic Development Corporation.


 

Comeback Places: Roxbury Revival

By Robert O’Malley

The AHP-funded Sargent-Prince building in Roxbury’s Dudley Square.

In the 1980s, an arson epidemic swept through the Roxbury neighborhood of Boston. Property owners began to torch their buildings to earn insurance payments. Vacant lots and burned-out buildings scarred the Dudley corridor. The neighborhood, as one visitor put it, began to look like war-torn Beirut.

For years the neighborhood had been drifting into decline. In the years following the Second World War, waves of white residents migrated to the suburbs, leaving behind a largely low-income minority and immigrant population burdened by discrimination and with little access to credit. In the 1960s, great swaths of lower Roxbury were bulldozed as part of an urban renewal effort and a plan to build the Southwest Corridor, a highway linking the expressway with Route 95. 
 
At the nadir of the neighborhood’s decline in the late 1980s, concerned nonprofit organizations such as the Boston Foundation and the Riley Foundation collaborated with Roxbury residents to create the Dudley Street Neighborhood Initiative (DSNI), an organization to coordinate neighborhood redevelopment by linking vacant land with community development corporations (CDCs) eager to build housing on it.

Over the last 15 years DSNI and local CDCs have been building new commercial space and rental and ownership housing on vacant land left behind by the arson wave of the 1980s. Today, the streets of the Dudley Triangle (an area bordered by Dudley Street, Howard Avenue, Brookford Street, and Blue Hill Avenue) show a stunning array of new affordable housing wedged between the neighborhood’s older housing.

Jason Webb, director of operations at DSNI and director of Dudley Neighbors Inc., the land-trust arm of the organization, says a key factor in Roxbury’s rebirth has been the participation of residents in the redevelopment process. Shortly after its founding, DSNI and neighborhood residents developed a comprehensive community plan outlining the kind of housing, commercial development, and green space residents wanted to see developed in the community. In the 1990s, DSNI and local CDCs began to implement the plan. 

“The key is to have the residents leading the way,” says Mr. Webb, who grew up in the neighborhood and has been working at DSNI for almost 20 years. “You have to allow the community and the residents to speak on their own behalf, to come together to work on their legacy.”

View of Central Boston Elder Services’ new headquarters in Dudley Square.

Critical to the revival has been the work of Nuestra Comunidad Development Corporation, Madison Park Development Corporation, and Dorchester Bay Economic Development Corporation. Rooted in the community, these organizations have developed new housing and commercial space throughout the neighborhood. “I think that the role of the nonprofit is to tread where no one else will go,” says Evelyn Friedman, Nuestra Comunidad’s executive director. “We took the risk and acquired and developed strategically located buildings and land as a way to encourage development elsewhere. I think it has worked.”

Also critical to the revival have been collaborations among community organizations, the City of Boston, and local financial institutions. “The CDCs had to build confidence with the lenders and funders that we could do these projects,” says Ms. Friedman. “Ten years ago, I’m not sure we could have convinced the banks that we could do the Dartmouth Hotel project. We have done bigger and bigger projects successfully, so slowly their confidence in us has been growing.”

Over the years the Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston’s (the Bank) Affordable Housing Program (AHP) and Community Development advance have helped fund numerous neighborhood initiatives. In 1997, the Bank awarded a $180,000 grant through member Boston Private Bank & Trust Company to the Brook Avenue Cooperative, which was part of the original comprehensive community plan. The Brook Avenue initiative involved construction of new two- and three-family rental buildings, 30 of which are affordable to very low-income residents. The recipient of numerous AHP awards for Roxbury initiatives, Boston Private Bank & Trust Company has been a major financer of the Dudley neighborhood’s revival (see related article).

Dudley Square
In addition to widespread construction of new single- and multifamily housing on vacant lots throughout the Dudley neighborhood, the Dudley revival includes major renovations to Dudley Square — at one time the city’s second largest commercial district. Over the last decade, Nuestra Comunidad and Madison Park have ac- quired and renovated dilapidated commercial buildings to create new housing and commercial space in the square.

View of the AHP-funded Dartmouth Hotel in Dudley Square.

Recent initiatives include Madison Park’s renovation of Hibernian Hall and Nuestra Comunidad’s renovation of the historic Dartmouth Hotel building. Awarded a $313,000  AHP grant through member Bank of America Rhode Island, N.A., the Dartmouth Hotel created 65 units of rental housing (45 for very low- and low-income families) and ground-floor commercial space.

In addition to those initiatives, other developments in the square include a new headquarters for Central Boston Elder Services and a new commercial building developed by a local church group. In recent years, Walgreens and national clothing retailer Ashley Stewart have also opened stores in the square. In the spring, the city will begin renovating the landmark Ferdinand Building — one of the most visible but dilapidated buildings in the square — to serve as offices for several city departments.

Ms. Friedman says Nuestra Comunidad and Madison Park’s development efforts have given the city new confidence in investing there. “Somebody has to stick his neck out and take the risk,” she says.
“I think that when someone does this, even in a small way, government feels more comfortable stepping in.”

More than a decade after the formulation of a comprehensive plan, the Dudley neighborhood is showing clear signs of revival. New housing and retail space have been built in the square, new businesses are opening, and property values are rising. “When I first came here, we had gang warfare on Dudley Street,” says Ms. Friedman. “Every day someone was being shot or stabbed. The kids were just warring with each other. We still have a ways to go, but we are light years away from where we were.”

Gentrification
But as real estate values in Roxbury rise and the new Kroc community center (see story on page 7) begins construction, some in the community are increasingly concerned about gentrification. “The next 10 years is definitely going to be challenging,” says Mr. Webb. “We know we are going to have to fight gentrification. When you bring in this type of community center, you’re going to have people wanting to live close to it.”

New housing on Dudley Street in Roxbury.

Community activists, however, feel confident that Roxbury, despite its proximity to the center of the city, will continue to be affordable to low-income residents, largely because much of the housing developed over the last decade — including ownership housing — was built with land donated by Dudley Neighbors Inc.

“People who purchase from our land trust get very little equity,” says Mr. Webb. “We say that to folks up front. ‘If you are in the market to make money on your house, then this is not the program for you; but if you want to live in a quality home and have a sense of community and not pay high property taxes, then this is the house you will want.’” T