November 2026 Peer Analysis and Balance Sheet Strategies Update

Transcript for November 2026 Peer Analysis and Balance Sheet Strategies Update

Thank you for joining us.

Happy to have you with us as we go through our webinar today, our peer analytics and balance sheet webinar.

So for those of you who don’t know, I’m Andrew, this is Tyler. The plan for today, we’ll take you through a couple different areas.

We’ll start by talking about what’s happening in the markets and the economy right now.

Absolutely nothing, but we’ll discuss the path of rates and the key economic metrics that concerns the Fed and informs what happens with rates.

Then we’ll dig into the third- quarter call reports for banks and credit unions and identify some key trends that we are watching closely and think will have implications for our third section here, balance sheet strategies, so the types of things that we can be doing and thinking about.

More thinking than doing, as good balance sheet managers do, on the funding side, but also on the asset side as well.

And then a new addition to this webinar, for those who have joined us in the past, as we’ve mentioned, this is one of the favorite things that we get to do, roll up our sleeves and really get the finger on the pulse of what’s happening for banks and credit unions in New England. And it’s a shame that we only have 45 minutes.

Well, for us, you’re probably saying it should be shorter.

But, you know, there’s a lot that goes on the cutting room floor to get into the allotted time slot.

But we have an appendix with about two dozen slides or so that didn’t make its way into the meat of the presentation, but we want to include there.

So if you’re extremely bored and need some good material to put yourself to sleep, or find a good idea or two, then there’s some stuff there that may be of help for you.

Just want to say thank you all for joining the call today, because last week, as many of us know, email wasn’t cooperating for a stretch of time.

And so as we send these invites out via email, The fact that Microsoft Outlook was down was not really helpful to the cause.

So similar to the icy reaction that Jalen Brown gave his old frenemy, I guess, in Jason Tatum last week when they played for the first time.

But nonetheless, we survived, we thrived, we’re here.

We also managed to make it through the grounded flights on Friday.

The pterodactyls flying in Mexico.

I don’t know if anybody saw that.

That was down the list of things happening in the news.

But, and then, you know, important to many, Grand Theft Auto 6 was released today.

So again, the fact that you’re here and not taking, as someone said earlier, the GTA flu, so that you’re able to carve some time out to talk peer analytics and balance sheet strategies with us is very much appreciated.

So let’s dive in to the first section here. We’ll talk about the markets and economy.

Tyler, why don’t you tell everybody what the heck is happening with interest rates? Quite a bit of volatility recently.

So what we’re looking at on this slide is the recent movements in the two- and the five-year treasury.

And we’ve seen quite a large move up, as we know, that happened from the late part of the up through about two weeks ago.

And part of that was, you know, to run up on expectations of inflation, many things like that.

We did have a flight to safety more recently that brought rates down, but then just as fast or faster than we got them back, or then we got some relief, we gave it right back.

Part of that was some fears related to some stronger economic prints that came through, which increased fears of sustained higher inflation and the Fed having to keep that more hawkish posture for longer.

But we did see, after this chart ends just in the last few days, it’s ready to come down about four or five basis points as we’ve seen some more hawkish comments from, say, Fed Chair Warsh and some other Fed speakers.

So we’ll see if that has a continued effect or if we remain in this slightly higher posture going forward.

One thing, and this tees up the next slide, to keep in mind is that, while our liabilities are repricing very quickly, it’s not as easy to pass on those increases, say, onto loan yields.

So that’s kind of what we’re looking at here is seeing what has happened with the six-month Treasury today versus six months ago.

So that’s what this chart see examines.

So in 2023, when we had that really parabolic rise in rates, it was very consistent that the six-month Treasury was much higher at the current day than it was six months ago.

So you’re putting on CDs, repricing them, much more expensive than you had them on previously.

Over the last couple of years, we saw a lot of relief as rates started to drop.

We actually saw some cuts materialize, but they were at least priced in over much of that period.

So you’re able to reprice CDs much more cheaply than you’d put them on six months ago.

But that’s changed as we’ve seen that movement rates that we looked at the last slide.

Since rates have come up, we’re putting on CDs at a much more expensive rate.

And so that’s something we’re going to look at for the rest of the deck.

So, Tyler mentioned that we’ve seen a whipsaw in term rates over the last couple weeks and months here with the recent pop in term rates and increasing expectations for near-term Fed hikes driven by a very solid unemployment print, but then also the continued higher and persistent inflation.

When we think about the different ways to look at inflation, we can look at year-over-year change, and we can break it down and try to assess the components and the impact of what’s happened, the geopolitical happenings in the Middle East as it relates to energy costs back here.

But when we look at market-based measures of inflation, pulled out from Treasury inflation protected securities, and a forward-looking measure of that.

So what is the expected five-year inflation rate five years forward?

And contrast that to nominal Treasury rates here, 10-year Treasury rates.

We don’t see the market generally super concerned that inflation is going to be a runaway problem.

And you’re probably saying, well, okay, well, how is that the case when that’s all the feds talking about and we see parabolic rises over a short period of time in spot rates. Well, there’s a lot more that goes into the push-and-pull on interest rates at the long of the curve and Beyond just inflation and I, so I think that the biggest driver is the term premium the volatility and the risk of committing and lending your funds further out the curve.

So, the scaling doesn’t always move hand in hand here, in terms of where nominal rates are versus where the more muted moves in inflation, but the direction there tends to be some correlation.

But again, it’s about the volatility that impacts that.

And one thing that we saw over the summer when rates started to rise.

The bond markets can be extremely complicated, but they can be extremely simple sometimes.

And there’s a rate or there’s a level where the marginal buyer says the reward matches the risk.

There’s an old bond market saying that there’s no bad bonds, just bad prices.

And again, it can be as scientific as you want it to be, but sometimes that level is a round number.

And 5% has tended to be that round number.

So as we’re approaching that level and in that intermediate part of the curve, we might see a little bit of a pause in stabilization here in rates, because at some point absent catastrophic concerns about the viability of the U.S. and the dollar and all those other things, which is a whole other discussion, the economics and the marginal buyer may quell the backup in long-term rates.

So when we think about Fed policy and how that impacts interest rates, the Fed, in some ways, is in a fortunate position right now because, as we’ve talked about in our FOMC videos, and I’m sure many of you have seen in many different channels, the laser focus is on inflation and bringing price stability back to where they need it and want it to be.

It would be much more challenging for the Fed if unemployment and the labor markets were sending mixed signals and there was contradictory impact in terms of what they needed and wanted to do to tackle inflation versus what was happening in the labor market.

So there can be a hawkish bend.

There can be rate hikes taken as action.

It would be awfully difficult for that to happen if there was weakness in the labor markets, right?

So up top, when we look at the national unemployment rate versus the path of Fed funds, we can see, going back to 2024, that it doesn’t take much in terms of an uptick in the national unemployment rate to get the Fed to either pause rate hikes or to initiate rate cuts, so that we have seen the trend nationally generally moving down.

That has given the Fed really the all-clear signal to really lock in on tackling inflation.

And the chart on the bottom is very interesting because, you know, that’s all well and good.

We can talk about the national or the broad-based numbers.

But as everyone on this call who manages a depository balance sheet knows that we exist in our local markets, in our regional markets.

So when we look at the unemployment rate in our six New England states, we see some different stories.

We see Connecticut at higher levels and rising, which is an outlier directionally versus what’s happening nationally versus Rhode Island and Massachusetts.

And then when you get into the three northern New England states, and I, in September and October, did a number of things with the banking associations up there, so I’m well versed on what’s happening in northern New England economically these days.

But you can see the absolute low levels of rates, so that even that Vermont and Maine aren’t necessarily declining, I’m not too worried about lack of declines and going sideways, because the levels are so low. You’re talking two handles versus the fours where we are nationally.

So, you know, clock that trend in Connecticut, because there’s a slide later in the presentation that this is going to come back to be useful to talk about.

So, let’s jump into talking about what’s happening in call report land. So, you know, first and foremost, let’s talk about margin.

And utilizing it at very strong levels, right?

So a net interest margin, median net interest margin for banks was up about six basis points over the quarter.

And we did see lift in the bottom quartile and the top quartile as well.

So in past quarters, if you were with us, you noticed that we made observations that certainly in the beginning of the rate-hiking cycle that there was a divergence, right?

Between the winners and losers, that not everybody was moving in lockstep, right?

The folks who were positioned more favorably for those moves and rates were able to capture and realize some of those benefits.

So as we sit here right now, whether you are a C &I lender with all floating-rate loans or you have fixed-rate mortgages on the books and large investment borrow, whatever composition or interest rate positioning you have, you do have asset pricing tailwinds helping you out right now, and everybody, as we’ll see in a little bit, is challenged and pressured on the deposit side.

Credit unions, again, we didn’t see the quarter-over-quarter jump in margins, but that’s okay because we’re already in the high threes and saw a more rapid increase earlier in the cycle than it as relative to banks.

So that’s good news.

Relatively not as good news is something that jumps out to us.

And we do analytics, and we see the benefit of looking narrowly inside of New England, because that’s where our members compete and operate in.

But sometimes it is instructive to look what’s happening on a broader scale.

And so here we’ve organized some of the similar types of data that we normally do, but breaking it out by the 11 different federal home loan bank districts.

And the takeaway is it’s awfully difficult to manage a depository here in New England.

And so you can see the median net initial margins or that middle 50% really stands out here in New England.

And then we’ve done some work on this in terms of the demographic reasons of why this is.

And when you think about in terms of population or in terms of land area, that is within, call it 50 or 100 miles of a major city, however you’d want to define a major city, that there’s much more concentration here in New England. And what happens when concentration is that leads to more competition.

So you have a greater presence from the national and the super-regional banks on top of the community banks and the credit unions.

And that puts pressure on both sides of the business, whether it’s the loan yields or the funding costs.

Again, you can see here highlighted by the green dot for both banks and credit unions, Boston is a little bit of an outlier and not in a particularly positive way because we can see the lowest, and the bank side, the lowest loan yields and close to the highest cost of funds.

You can see the only two districts where cost of funds is higher is in San Francisco and New York, which again have some very similar demographic and economic profiles, as we do have here in New England.

On the credit union side, it is a little bit better in terms of the cost of funds closer to middle of the pack nationally, but again the pressure on the loan yields is pretty significant.

So now we’re going to take a look at what was driving the increase in net interest income.

So starting on the left side, we’re going to look at banks.

What we’re doing here is looking at the full breakdown of the membership by both banks and credit unions.

So almost like it’s one big bank and one big credit union, looking at the aggregate changes in millions of dollars.

So starting on the left side with banks, we see that asset yields increasing, delivering $131 million in additional income this quarter, whereas funding costs reduced income by about 42 million, and then the mix was negative by about $7 million for banks, whereas the actual increase in the amount of earning assets was positive by 57 million, coming together for an aggregate total change of $140 million in additional income for banks.

So we’re seeing here that as much as better yields are helping and costs are negative, it’s actually the increase in the amount of assets is sizably helpful as well.

And then turning to the right side, on credit unions, we see asset yields up $13 million, but funding costs, completely wiping that out at $13 million negative.

So really, much of the increase is coming from positive funding mix, as well as an increase in earning assets, which are delivering a total net interest income, 17 million in additional net interest income in Q3 versus Q2.

So now, looking at, with this additional income, is that flowing through to return on assets?

So looking at banks on the left side and credit unions on the right side again, we see that here we’re breaking down banks that are flat or down on return on assets versus in gray versus blue for the ones who rose.

And so we see that in both cases, the income was up by about 10 basis points, but fee income was down for those where ROA was down, versus about flat for those where it rose.

And then operating expense was lower for those who grew ROA and up for those who didn’t.

So what we’re seeing here is, as much as it’s about increasing your income, being able to manage expense and then also have good performance on fees is really what a lot of the difference is in actual ROA performance or where it comes from.

And then again, onto the right side for credit unions, seeing here that there’s a little bit of a bifurcation here where for the ROA down or flat they did see a little bit less of an increase in income basis points but really again you know the difference in our way was driven more by the less fee income on those who performed lower on our way and then better for those who did better on our way and then again on operating expense, 7 basis points higher for those who had lower ROA in the quarter versus about flat for those who were able to increase ROA this quarter.

Okay, so let’s talk about loan growth.

Before we get into loan growth, a friendly reminder, if you have any questions, feel free to drop those in the chat.

So when we start to segment loan growth by buckets, we see an interesting trend.

And we’ve talked about this for a number of quarters here.

Qualitatively or intangibly, folks are describing, I think many members are pleasantly surprised at the loan pipeline.

Now there are certainly exceptions where it’s really starting to turn a little bit and demand is softening.

But it’s been kind of sort of OK to use a technical way of talking about it.

But we see two different trends here were in credit unions, there’s been a slight shift to more members experiencing greater growth.

So when we think about the percentage of members who are able to get into that north of 5% loan growth bucket, when we add those top two buckets, it gets to about 46% right now.

We rewind that a year was only 37%. So an extra 11% of credit units are able to get mid-single digits and above.

Whereas in banks, the trend is the opposite, that exceptional growth level that is starting to shrink a little bit. And that’s borne out when we look at the median loan growth.

We’re seeing those numbers really start to converge about to the 3% and 4% level, which is good.

But, you know, given that we are in this challenging rate environment that is wholly different than anything that we’ve seen, both on the short and the long end of the last few years, and certainly overlay that with geopolitical risk and Fed risk and all these types of things, that it’s tough to blame anybody to be not cautiously optimistic, but just cautious about where low growth may go from here.

And so now we’re looking at both loan growth and comparing that with deposit growth and seeing where banks and credit unions are able to grow both or maybe have flatter down performance.

So what we’re looking at here is in blue are the banks, the 166 Federal Home Loan Bank of Boston banks and then the credit unions in green.

And so starting from the left, we’re looking at where both loan growth and deposit growth were both up.

So that was 57% of banks.

So the majority of banks had growth on both sides of the balance sheet.

And then a little bit less than half of credit unions were able to grow on both sides.

And then looking one more to the right, we’re looking at loans up versus deposits being flattened down.

And so we see that for banks, loans being up where deposits not growing was about 22%, but it was stronger for credit unions.

There’s about 40% of credit unions who were able to grow loans, but had deposits flattened down.

And then looking at where deposit growth outran loan growth, that was a much smaller group.

So about 10% of banks and only 11% of credit unions.

And then where both were down was 11% in both the banks and credit unions.

So we’re seeing growth on both sides of the balance sheet in most members right now, especially on the bank side.

And now we’re going to look at the next slide is, how are banks and credit unions funding that growth?

So we’re looking by core tile, so banks on top, credit unions on the bottom, and the different colors are showing where the growth was funded.

So if you look at the bottom, those are the different categories.

And we’re working from left to right as far as the quartile, so the lowest quartile of growth on the left and then the fastest-growing banks on the right and working in that direction.

And so we see that the banks that had the lowest growth funded more with advances and other balance sheet items.

We saw that in credit unions too, mostly funding with some deposits, as well as advances in those lower-growing quartiles.

But then, starting with the banks now, again, if we work to the right and look at the higher-growing banks, they’re funding more with deposits.

And that effect increases if we go to the third quartile and then the highest quartile, where most of that growth was being funded by deposits rather than, say, cash or advances.

But then in the credit unions, a very different dynamic was playing out where actually the faster growing credit unions were leaning much more into cash deployment.

Cash deployment, securities runoff and that were sold and using that instead to fund the growth.

So very interesting kind of seeing the two different strategies and where the growth is coming from currently.

Yeah, that’s a good observation about the incremental growth versus the remixing of the asset side.

And we’ll come back to that topic of growth as we get into the strategies on slide three.

So again, sticking with that perspective of sometimes it’s good to zoom out and look at a national level how things match up.

So, you know, despite the lagging on net interest margin, we can see the loan to deposits tells us a couple things that is probably not too surprising to many of us who live and operate here in New England is that loan-to-deposit or loan-to-share ratios are pretty high, right?

And that’s a function of two things, right?

The robust and diversified economy that we have here in New England, but also the knife right, that is trying to bring in deposits.

So that affects both sides, the numerator and the denominator here.

And obviously, as you can infer that higher loan-to-deposit ratio is going to lead to higher advances utilization.

And I’ve tried to tell important people around here that higher utilization is because of the charm and intelligence of member facing staff and they always laugh.

They never just say, okay, that’s a great observation, but in all seriousness, there are the economic and demographic reasons that, naturally, that loans deposit and loan-to-share ratios, I don’t want to say stretched, but they’re going to be closer to higher levels that means that you’re going to have to manage liquidity differently than if the garden-variety bank or credit union has 30 to 40% bond portfolio and an easy time gathering deposits.

So talking about segueing into gathering deposits, here’s a look at aggregate, which we can look at things in a couple of different ways.

We look at mediums and percentiles, but sometimes it is good to look at aggregates despite the impact, the outsize impact you know, from one or two or a handful of large members.

But I think it’s important to see the divergence for banks and credit unions on the deposit strategy.

And we’ll get into deposit pricing strategy a little bit later.

So banks were actually able to decline or see a decline in term deposits where credit unions increased quarter over quarter, but big jumps in non-term deposits for banks were very incrementally higher for credit units, but paled in comparison to the CD.

So, you know, when we get into talking about some strategies and then how the yield curve has shifted in terms of the level, but more importantly, the slope of the yield curve, I think that has big time implications for what product that we’re out there leading with that we’re hoping to gain traction with and how we can check off all the boxes risk-wise and return-wise with our product selection and pricing.

So now we’re going to take a look at deposit cost and then CD reliance.

And then what happened over the last year, and how much CD reliance was able to both help or hurt banks and credit unions over the last year with the change in rates.

So we’re looking at starting on the left with the banks is the change in annualized deposit cost by quartile. Again, starting the left with the lowest, the quartiles are looking at here are the CD the share of CDs as a percentage of deposits in Q3 of 2025 so looking back a year and then seeing you know what the effect was of that CD concentration, or lack thereof, on the change in total deposit costs over the year.

So starting on the left, we see that from Q3 2025 to Q2 2026, the lowest percentage share of CED quartile was able to see deposit costs come down by about 17 basis points over the nine months from Q3 last year to last quarter.

But then in the last quarter, CD costs were up by about five basis points.

And then working to the right, we see that the highest CD, having the highest percentage of CDs as a percentage of deposits, meant that over the last year, you did see an increase in reduction in deposit cost.

But over the last quarter, that effect has been muted.

So the change, five basis points, increase for the lowest percentage, and then to the point of right to the two basis points.

You’re seeing that having the lower percent of CDs has been less helpful more recently.

And then going to the right to the credit unions, we’re seeing is that over the last year, having that higher percentage of CDs, you were able to see some reduction in deposit costs, 16 basis points for the highest quartile, and then five basis points for the lowest quartile.

But then over the last quarter, the change has been really pretty much the same between three basis points across the three high-score tiles and then two basis points on the lowest.

So you’re seeing that being able to have a lower percentage of CDs currently is not having as much of an effect as it was over the last nine months.

Yeah, and to your slide from the first section is, I think as we look forward here, it’s going to be more challenging, right?

Because you live by the sword, die by the sword.

With the CDs coming due, subject to where market rates are right now.

And we’re higher where we were relative to where they were put on, it’s probably going to create some funding pressure.

Absolutely.

And then we’re looking at here is that the duration of the CD book and what’s changed, say, year over year.

So looking at banks on the left side, the breakdown of deposits maturing in the next year, in the next one to three years, and then three years plus.

So last year, this time, it was 92% of CDs were maturing inside the next year, that’s actually come down to about 90.7%.

That’s actually in line with some things that we’ve heard ALM providers talk about, we’ve actually been talking about, which is trying to edge out the curve a little bit, go a little bit longer in duration on CDs.

And so we actually are sort of seeing that whether it be intentional or consumer behavior driving it, either way, CDs are getting longer in duration over the last year. But on the credit union side, it’s more of a muted effect.

Really, things are just about flat really year over year in that CD concentration, sorry, CD duration.

So kind of interesting seeing that, you know, banks are going a little bit longer out in CD duration.

Credit unions started shorter and have stayed pretty much where they were a year ago.

Sorry, it started longer and stayed longer.

So the newest member of our team, Tom Hamaker, who’s on the first-line credit risk management side, did some work on capital for us as a good professional does focuses on capital. This is an interesting observation.

We talked about the improvements in NIM in profitability and the surprisingly okay loan demand and growth.

What happens is that capital growth and buildup is exceeding asset growth right now.

Capital ratios are improving.

And part of that, and there’s two parts of that, because the asset growth is tame, right? It’s not run away.

It’s not high single digits or even double digits like we saw going back a number of years.

But obviously that capital growth number is aided by when you have more ROE, it’s going to grow, right?

So profitability will stress there.

So, you know, this tees up what we’ll get to when we pivot to Section 3, that there’s a lot of conditions that are in favor of being primed for growth right now.

First and foremost, that we’re seeing capital ratios improve, and you can see on the right-hand side the percentage of banks who are at higher levels of capital now than they were at various points in the past.

So now I’ll pivot and take a look at what’s going on with asset quality.

And you know, with capital ratios being a little bit higher, there is a little bit more room for say, some asset quality pain, but either way, we’re going to see where we stand and things are getting a little bit worse quarter over quarter, though we are flat from the beginning of the year for banks.

So looking at a 30 plus day nonaccrual, and this is across all the banks in our New England membership.

And so across all loans, like I said, up over the quarter but flat since the beginning of the year, as we start to break it out by different loan categories, we do see quite a bit of diversity here in what’s going on.

So in the one to four family closed down, it’s up quarter over quarter, but down from the beginning of the year, but we do see HELOCs consistently trending down in rate, which is a little bit potentially surprising where rates are consistently higher and rising on those HELOCs.

And then we’re seeing a lot of utilization, a lot of growth in those portfolios so good to see that things are trending in the right direction on asset quality there though of course starting from a higher place maybe that’s a better takeaway things are just reverting back to mean or to normal performance higher home values probably yeah right absolutely and then Cree was definitely getting worse on both sides both owner occupied non-owner occupied and then consumer surprisingly kind of flat we know we’re hearing a lot of concern about what’s going to happen with the health the consumer, you know, potentially some concern about consumer loans, but up over the quarter, but just barely up year over year at a high rate, you know, 1.5%, but still not anything really running away or overly concerning yet.

Really on the bank side, the big takeaway is just commercial real estate.

And then on the credit union side, looking at total loans, really just barely up one basis point for 60 plus day delinquencies across our credit union membership base over quarter and then up more from Q1 but like we’ve talked about many times Q1 tends to trend lower for credit unions with a larger denominator on the you know with the loan growth so really we can look at this as probably being just about flat from the beginning of the year over the last three quarters.

Auto loans just ticking up a little bit, which is good to see you know some concern there as well with you know the terms getting longer and longer and some of these prices these new cars just being kind of hard to understand but not really leading through into performance.

So things look pretty strong there, and are actually getting better from the beginning of the year and just barely up from last quarter.

Credit cards, really again, not a terrible amount of concern as far as, and this also is including all unsecured, as well as credit cards, up a little bit over from the beginning of the year, but actually down from last quarter.

Commercial real estate, however, is ticking up a tremendous amount, but 10 basis points from last quarter.

And we’ll look at this a little bit in the two slides, kind of seeing that a lot of the overall change, you know, as far as the total loan performance with banks and credit unions really being driven by just a few, you know, banks and credit unions that are having some trouble in commercial real estate.

But then finally, on the one to four family residential, things really basically again flat from last quarter, up one basis point, but up about 15 basis points from Q1.

Again, we usually see about 10 basis points of a change from, sorry, we usually see Q1 being about 10 basis points lower just from that effect that happens every year.

So maybe we can see this as about a five-basis point increase on one to four family.

Really nothing tremendously concerning, but we’ll continue to watch this.

Well, much like Northern New England unemployment levels, like if it’s at a low starting rate, an uptake isn’t the same as an uptake where the level is higher to begin with.

Exactly, and now we’re going to see you know is the what’s going on with the credit pipeline are there more cockroaches under the mat Or are we are we in good shape going forward and it looks like well, you know on the bank side things are potentially turning in the wrong direction as far as the 30 to 89 day past due taking up five basis points from Q2 and then it was flat from q3 of last year. So flat year-over-year.

Sorry a five basis point year-over-year But as we look at that 90 plus day not accruable those loans that are really starting to get concerning That is trending up, you know, pretty much five basis points Or sorry, this is not QQQ It’s Q year-over-year from the left to the far right and then from quarter to quarter from the middle to the right So nine basis points up year-over-year and then four basis points up from last quarter We’ll see if that continues and if that leads through to charge drops and into overall asset quality measures.

Then on the credit union side, looking to the right, 30- to 59-day, actually trending in the right direction, down slightly a quarter over quarter and down about five basis points from this time last year, but the 60-plus day is moving in the wrong direction.

More year over year, so nine basis points, less from last quarter, so less acceleration So credit unions are actually in better shape, whereas banks are moving potentially in the wrong direction.

Though as we’re going to see in this next slide, a lot of that is being driven by more of a few banks who are having issues rather than a broad-based deterioration.

So what we’re looking at here is what actually moved the problem asset ratio.

So now, again, we’re looking at the membership as one big banks.

We’re kind of throwing them all together and seeing both banks on the left and the credit unions on the right what drove that overall percentage change, and so we see the problem loan dollars were up 4.5 basis points in banks and 3.1 basis points in credit unions as far as what was driving so sorry 4.5 basis points of the chain was driven by problem loan dollars but the loan denominator was helping so the growth in loans held by 9.9 basis points on banks and then held by 1.7 basis points on credit unions.

So it’s interesting to see that despite the growth in problem loan dollars, the ability to grow loans is kind of hiding some of that effect and reducing the overall net change, so 3.7 basis points in banks and 1.4 basis points in credit unions.

And then looking at the table on the right, we’re looking at kind of the overall change in millions of dollars, like I’m looking at kind of one big bank, one big credit union.

So gross increases of 315 million, 50 million credit unions offset by declines of 125 million and about 30 million for credit unions and the net increases but interestingly, and this is what I was teeing up a few slides ago, so the top five increases in problem assets and then how much of a percentage of the total change in problem assets out of all the banks and credit unions is about half of the reform in banks, and 30% of the total change was driven by the top five credit unions.

So we’re really seeing a concentration in deterioration rather than a broad-based problem developing.

I think that’s a great observation on the concentration versus the broad-based impact.

So I had mentioned a while back about unemployment and put a pin in that in terms of looking at the directionality here.

So when we look at MBAs, this is combining banks and credit We see an interesting dynamic where it’s starting to take up, as Tyler alluded to, when we got a little more granular.

But which one of these things is unlike the other?

We can see the MPA ratio in Connecticut is declining, and that’s polar opposite to what we saw on the unemployment side.

So you would imagine there’s a little bit of a lagging effect in terms of how unemployment and MPAs will relate to each other.

But I just thought that really the dichotomy of how those things interact is something worth monitoring.

So let’s get into balance sheet strategies and what we can do from here.

So I think first and foremost, when we think about the shape of the yield curve, we think about the strength in the economy, broadly speaking.

Conditions are prime for growth, right?

when we have a positively slope yield curve for the first time in forever, essentially, and we have loan demand, and we have liquidity, and we have capital built up, then that tells us that all the permutations that we can have in terms of growth, whether it’s loans funded by deposits, loans funded by wholesale, investments funded by wholesale, that the arithmetic is going to be accretive ROE and ROE.

So, contrast that to those times when the yield curve was inverted and we were reluctantly trying to grow and impacting our rate risk profile, our margin and all those types of things.

You know, after that, it’s okay, great, growth is fantastic, but that’s going to have impact on the risk profile.

It’s not as easy as just saying, go do the thing that makes sense right now, and then the characteristics of the balance sheet are going to change.

So in first and foremost, the deposit franchise and composition is the core of what makes a good banker credit union run.

So certainly that has to be first and foremost, because the irony is as challenging it is to bring in deposits right now.

In a higher-rate environment, the upside of having a great deposit franchise is that much greater, because you can’t deploy those cheap, sticky deposits much more impactfully.

And so lastly, given that conditions are changing, then I think the things that we have to think about and the things that we have to put into practice should naturally change as well, right?

Like, unless you really have that golden goose operation where deposits fall to the sky and good quality high-yielding loans are easy to come by, then there has to be, at least on the margin, some pivot in strategy and approach.

So we talked about how it’s a favorable environment for growth.

So this is an asset version of that liability chart that Tyler showed in the first section.

And so it’s looking at the five-year Treasury rate, using that as a proxy for the point on the curve where many of our assets are probably pegged off of, that when we see the difference versus where we were five years ago, there’s an awful lot of opportunity.

So you might have had a loan that you did five years ago to the day, based off, priced off of the five-year home loan bank advance, that is probably, the existing coupon is less than what you are earning at IORB right now.

So even if that loan were to completely pay off and not refund, you’re talking about margin expansion.

So auto loans have, because of the shorter duration, have mostly priced through, but as we all know, there’s a lot of first-rate mortgage exposure and investment exposure that is, time is starting to heal those wounds, even though we did see some uptick in the unrealized loss last quarter.

So, but if your capital position allows, we’ve been having more conversations, both one-on-one conversations, but even at our CEO CFO Roundtable event a few weeks back, the topic of deploying that capital, leaning into the positively sloped yield curve to pre-fund or grow the investment portfolio, to hedge the risk for the institution of lower long-term rates and a flatter yield curve.

The time and the opportunity may be there right now.

And if your interest rate risk position allows to take some to continue to lend or invest off of that that that intermediate part of the curve because when you’re talking about certainly you know at these higher rates DSER or payments on mortgages may be challenging from the bar perspective, but that’s not really an issue if you’re buying 6% bonds so there could be some opportunity there Absolutely, and speaking to that, you know, leaning into this really opportune yield curve environment, what we’re going to look at here is the difference in the nominal two-year.

We’re going to look at the nominal two-year and then how that relates to the steepness in the five-year, two-year Treasury curve.

And so what we see here, it’s a very opportune time.

So the green dots are Q4, the Q4 prints in Treasury steepness, and then in two-year nominal.

And then the blue is everything from 2000 to Q3 2026.

And so we see is as far as steepness, we’re in a really good spot, but from a nominal perspective, the tier is quite high.

So as much as it’s a great time to lean into asset growth, putting on bonds, we do have to be careful about managing CD and just overall deposit costs, both as far as mix, and then just with the actual pricing that we’re putting onto those, either specials or just our total rate rack.

So a few strategies that we are advising right now to consider in light of this is pricing in terms of the spread to advances or other just-in-time liquidity sources.

So thinking about whether you’re 20- to 25- basis points below advances and then going further out the curve and looking at where that spread is and being able to create some advantageous pricing by say going out two or three years down the curve If you can find demand, and then looking at what the spread to treasuries is relative to the nominal, and there’s some really good opportunities there, and then just in general pricing to advances, and then also leaning into money markets relative versus CDs, and then lastly just being really, really mindful of cannibalization and tracking how much funds are coming out of those sticky low-cost deposits and going into higher-cost promos, measuring that, and then considering the all-in costs and how that relates to the cost of other just-in-time liability sources, like advances.

So when we think about the wholesale funding solutions, again, as I mentioned, conditions change, so should strategies, or at least things that we get the tires on.

So when we talk about investment leverage, for example, think about the different ways that we can think about liquidity.

There’s on-balance sheet liquidity, there’s off-balance sheet liquidity, And then there’s the cash flow over a three- or six-month period.

So buying bonds and funding it with floating-rate advances, where maybe there’s a six-month term, but you get that overnight exposure.

So it’s going to support on-balance-sheet liquidity, because those bonds come on, and that is supportive of the liquidity ratio.

It’s a use of off-balance-sheet liquidity.

But in terms of the assets produced cash flow, which is going to be supportive of any liquidity analysis, but the maturity of the wholesale funding is a little bit out.

So if you’re looking over the course of 90 days and it’s a six-month borrowing, then that is not going to be a use of that liquidity.

So investment leverage to our prior point about margin support and interest rate risk mitigation, there can be some liquidity benefits there as well.

Our puttable advances have been supremely popular, as many are familiar with the HLB option.

But one of the interesting things there is that the appeal for that product is often most favorable when conditions for the core business of your balance sheet are not favorable, when the curve is inverted and things like that.

So now that here we are to our prior point where, hey, if you have the ability to continue to lend and get deposits at shorter parts of the curve, then the shine is off on some of those core products.

So I think if we were to continue to utilize those products, as many members do, then there’s going to be value maybe in some of the shorter structures with shorter lockouts.

So rather than doing the five-year, one-year type structure, you’re not getting the real juice and cost savings.

Maybe something like the two-year, three-year is more favorable. The other avenue to look there would be the sulfur flipper advance. So that is a floating-to-fixed rate advance.

Again, that a very similar type approach, but more favorable given the shape of the yield curve right now and certainly can be used in investment leverage.

But then again, as we push and pull-on interest rate risk, there’s different avenues and ways to mitigate that.

And so talking a lot about season loan sales of the existing residential mortgage book.

The three is at 80.

I don’t think the math is probably favorable.

But as we’ve talked about those mid coupons, those fives and sixes in that 90% and higher range, there could be some opportunity to de-lever and even see the capital ratio go up or to fund the incremental loan growth happening in higher-spread type areas, like autos or commercial loan.

And if you are a credit union and you’re feeling pain on the NEV test with the backup in rates here, or a bank who is sensitive to the EV calculation, the member option advance is certainly something that would be worthwhile to take a look at.

Because again, it’s the path of least resistance to mitigating those results.

Not quite the same impact of ripping off the band aid of repositioning the asset side.

So that brings us to the end here.

Thank you all for joining us again through the trials and tribulations of having our emails reach your inbox.

But as always, if there’s anything that we can be of assistance with, you know where to find us.

And I hope everybody has a fantastic Thanksgiving, and I hope we will speak to you all soon.

Bye.

Thank you.